Blog / Why +10% Then −10% Does Not Break Even: Arithmetic and Geometric Average Returns

Why +10% Then −10% Does Not Break Even: Arithmetic and Geometric Average Returns

Returns act on a changing amount. Add percentages to describe their simple average; multiply growth factors to find a chained outcome.

October 7, 2026 · 6 min read · By Cepingku Editorial Team

‘Up 10 percent, then down 10 percent, so I am back where I started’ adds percentage returns while ignoring that each return acts on a different amount. In this fictional teaching example, 100 becomes 100 × (1 + 10%) = 110 after the first equal-length period. The next −10% applies to 110, so the ending value is 110 × (1 − 10%) = 99. The cumulative return from 100 to 99 is (99 ÷ 100) − 1 = −1 percent. These are invented amounts, not a price, historical return, or forecast.

The calculation works by turning each return into a growth factor: 1.10 for +10% and 0.90 for −10%. Chained periods require their product, 1.10 × 0.90 = 0.99, rather than 10% + (−10%). Will Morrison’s 2015 CFA Institute Enterprising Investor post explains the same mathematical distinction: the geometric mean corresponds to a product, and an ending value is the initial value multiplied by one plus each periodic return. This article uses only that principle. It does not treat a blog post as empirical investment research, or reproduce its tables or historical data.

QuestionCalculation in this fictional two-period example
What changed over both periods?100 × 1.10 × 0.90 = 99, a cumulative return of −1%.
What is the simple average of the stated returns?(10% + (−10%)) ÷ 2 = 0%.
What fixed periodic return reaches the same end value?√0.99 − 1 ≈ −0.5013% per period.

Arithmetic and geometric means answer different questions

The arithmetic mean adds the stated periodic percentages and divides by the number of periods. It answers the simple average of those two reported numbers, which is zero in this example. It does not claim that compounding 0% for two periods produces 99. The arithmetic mean is built from a sum.

The geometric mean starts from the product of the growth factors. Here the two-period factor is 0.99. Find one fixed factor g such that g² = 0.99: g = √0.99. The fixed periodic return is therefore √0.99 − 1 ≈ −0.0050126, or about −0.5013% per period. Applying that fixed return twice gives 100 × (1 − 0.0050126)², approximately 99. The geometric mean answers a different question: what constant periodic rate would connect this same starting value and ending value?

A 0% arithmetic average and an approximately −0.5013% geometric average are not competing answers. One comes from the sum of percentages; the other comes from the product of growth factors. Before using the word ‘average return,’ identify which calculation is intended and what it is meant to describe.

State the amount, percentage, and time unit

The same +10%, −10% sequence produces a 0.99 ending factor whether the two equal periods are days, months, or years. But the phrase ‘about −0.5013% per period’ changes meaning with the period. It is not automatically an annual return. State whether one period is a day, month, or year before comparing it with another rate.

Keep money amounts separate from percentages too. In the fictional example, 99 is one currency unit below 100, which is a −1% change. Starting with 10,000 instead would end at 9,900 under the same factors: still −1%, but 100 currency units lower. The amount change depends on the starting amount; the percentage change expresses the relative movement.

When the simple example no longer fits

The calculation assumes two equal periods, no deposits or withdrawals between them, and no fees, taxes, distribution treatment, or other cash flows. External cash flows can make an end-versus-start comparison mix investment movement with money added or removed. Fees also change the periodic growth factors. In either case, the return method and the dates of cash flows need to be stated before drawing a conclusion.

A correctly calculated historical sequence remains historical; it does not predict the next period. When you see an average return, ask whether it is arithmetic or geometric, how many periods it spans, the unit of one period, and whether cash flows and fees are included. The Investment Approach Reflection can prompt reflection on how you read amounts, percentages, and chained changes. It does not offer investment advice, predict returns, or personalise this fictional calculation.

Want to see where you land?

Take the Investment Approach Reflection and get your results in minutes.

Take the Investment Approach Reflection →

← Back to the blog